Oniomania: A Look into the Minds of Compulsive Shoppers
By: Hindie M. Klein, PsyD
Published in Building Blocks, August 28th, 2013
Here‚Äôs a brief self-diagnostic quiz:
¬†‚ÄĘ Do you buy things you want, whether or not you can afford them at the moment?
¬†‚ÄĘ Do you buy things to cheer yourself up or to reward yourself?
¬†‚ÄĘ If you have to say no to yourself, or put off buying something you really want, do you feel intensely deprived, angry or upset?
These are some of the questions asked by Olivia Mellan and Sherry Christie, recovering shopaholics and the authors of Overcoming Overspending: A Winning Plan for Spenders and their Partners (Walker and Company, 2008). In their book, Mellan and Christie discuss the etiology of overspending, also known as compulsive shopping or ‚Äúoniomania.‚ÄĚ They explain why a person might become an over-spender or compulsive shopper and how, with the help of their partners, they can overcome this addiction.
That‚Äôs right, addiction. Oniomania may be considered an aspect of an impulse control disorder, or an obsessive-compulsive disorder. Also referred to as compulsive shopping, shopping addiction, shopaholism or compulsive buying (CB), recent research has indicated that oniomania has become a significant concern in our society, right up there with addictions such as alcoholism, eating disorders or substance abuse. About 90% of those affected are female, with age of onset starting in late teens or early twenties, and the condition is chronic. Some researchers report that there is a higher prevalence of compulsive shopping in women due to lower levels of serotonin. These women tend to shop compulsively, binge eat, or exhibit kleptomania. In addition, compulsive shoppers have been shown to have significantly higher rates of depression, anxiety, substance abuse, binge eating and impulse control disorders.
What determines the difference between someone who enjoys shopping because they are generous and want to buy things for others or because they take pleasure and pride in possessions, and a true shopaholic? Here are three symptomatic features of a compulsive shopper:
¬†1. Over-preoccupation with buying, anytime, anywhere ‚Äď in stores, online, and on TV (like Home Shopping Network)
¬†2. Feelings of distress, shame or guilt as a result of the activity (particularly noted at the point when the buying gets so out of hand that the compulsive shopper becomes secretive and hides the things they‚Äôve bought)
¬†3. The compulsive buying is not the result of or limited to hypomanic ormanic episodes.
¬†An Oniomania Profile
Compulsive shoppers try to counteract feelings of depression, anger, loneliness or low self-esteem through the emotional ‚Äúlift‚ÄĚ and momentary euphoria provided by compulsive shopping. Purchases can sometimes act as a symbol for the person‚Äôs ideal self. For example, a woman who is insecure about her looks may compulsively buy fashionable clothing or jewelry to feel more beautiful. When the compulsive shopper shops, endorphins are released and there is an adrenaline rush ‚Äďshopping is exciting! The rush may often be followed by a sense of shame, disappointment and guilt. Naturally, you want to feel the rush again. This behavior can spiral dramatically into an abyss of significant mental, financial, emotional, marital and familial distress.
In a study of 25 compulsive shoppers, Gary A. Christenson, MD and his colleagues found that compulsive shopping occurred episodically, from every few days to once a week, and that the urges typically lasted one hour. Those in the study most commonly experienced buying urges at home, but they also felt the desire to buy at work, in stores, in malls and while driving. Nearly all of the shoppers reported a release of tension or gratification after buying, followed by feelings of guilt, anger, sadness or indifference. More than half of the compulsive buyers reported that they never even removed the purchases from their packaging or that they returned purchases or disposed of the items in various ways. Shopaholics also tended to incur large debts.
A shopaholic often presents with a clinically significant profile that begins in early childhood. When there is a lack of parent-child attunement and nurturance at an early age, the child grows up feeling empty and bereft. Their identity is vacuous, empty and undependable, lacking the rich foundation that solid, loving parenting provides. Children who experience parental neglect often grow up feeling unimportant and uncared for, resulting in low self-esteem. They seek substitutes for their emptiness and often turn to toys or food to combat their loneliness and feelings of inadequacy. As they grow older, they are more likely to use ‚Äúobjects‚ÄĚ or other experiences such as food, drugs, or sex to soothe their feelings of deprivation. Often as adults, they lack the inner sense of peace and security that comes with a healthy sense of self. They may become impulsive, compulsive, controlling, or very needy of affection and ‚Äúthings‚ÄĚ to make them feel sated and relaxed.
I‚Äôm reminded of a situation I observed some years ago. I was in a dress shop and a well-dressed, attractive young woman came in and asked to speak to the owner. She began talking about a dress that was ‚Äúon hold‚ÄĚ in the back of the shop. It seems that this dress was quite costly, and seemingly beyond her means, as she was paying for it in small increments. She kept repeating, ‚ÄúIf my husband only knew, he‚Äôd kill me. I‚Äôm not allowed to buy any more clothes, I have so much, but this dress is so pretty.‚ÄĚ When the shop owner suggested that perhaps she shouldn‚Äôt buy this dress, because she truly couldn‚Äôt afford it, and because she already had so many ‚Äúpretty dresses,‚ÄĚ the young woman begged the shop owner to please, please allow her to pay it off this way. The scene was heart-wrenching. This young woman was distraught, nearly hysterical. The thought of not buying the dress was painful. She needed to buy that dress. Yet, rest assured that once this dress was purchased and taken home, there would be something new to buy. There always is.
For the compulsive shopper, the world can be a dangerous place. We are faced with a consumer culture that promotes spending, credit card debt, and ‚Äúshop till you drop‚ÄĚattitudes. Many things are sold in large, oversized fashion, the ‚Äúsuper-size me‚ÄĚ mentality. Everywhere you turn, there is the ability to buy and nowadays, with online and TV shopping, it is easily and always accessible to the consumer. No more having to get on the train or in your car and head for the mall. You can ‚Äúshop till you drop‚ÄĚ in the privacy of your own home, at any given hour of day or night.
Getting the Help You Need
One of the main problems in treating oniomania is that, as with eating, you usually can‚Äôt totally stop the behavior. When shopping gets truly out of hand and has become addictive, psychological intervention is usually the best course of treatment. In treatment, the compulsive shopper can learn the underlying symbolic meaning behind the constant need to shop and accumulate ‚Äúobjects‚ÄĚ and can learn ways to effectively stop the compulsive buying and not replace this habit with yet another compulsive habit.
In her book, To Buy or Not to Buy: Why We Overshop and How to Stop (Trumpeter: Boston and London, 2008), Dr. April Lane Benson notes that, ‚ÄúResearch confirms what psychologist Paul Wachtel so nicely termed, ‚ÄėThe Poverty of Affluence‚Äô in his 1983 book of that title. The more you believe that happiness comes from material wealth, the more likely you are to be depressed, distressed, and anxious ‚Äď and the less actual well-being you are likely to experience.‚ÄĚ As part of her treatment, Dr. Benson will ask her clients six questions for them to answer in writing when they are about to buy something. She feels that if you can answer these questions satisfactorily, you are probably not making a compulsive purchase. Answering these questions is also is a way to create space between the impulse and the action, which can help the person make a more mindful decision.
The six questions are as follows: Why am I here? How do I feel? Do I need this? What if I wait? How will I pay for it? Where will I put it?
Sure, shopping can be fun and can get you the things you want and need. But when you think about it, what one truly needs ‚Äď way beyond objects ‚Äďis a feeling of strong self-esteem and well-being, a sense of mastery and control, and a sense of true appreciation for the important people in your life and for the simple pleasures in your world.
Dr. Hindie M. Klein is the Director of Clinical Projects for OHEL Children‚Äôs Home and Family Services. Dr. Klein, a psychologist and psychoanalyst, maintains a private practice specializing in the treatment of children, adolescents, adults and couples. She can be reached at Hindie_klein@ohelfamily.org
Since 1969, OHEL Children‚Äôs Home and Family Services has served as a dependable haven of individual and family support, helping people of all ages surmount everyday challenges, heal from trauma, and manage with strength and dignity during times of crises. Driven by service excellence, OHEL‚Äôs professional staff meet the myriad social service needs of the general community, while at the same time providing culturally-sensitive services to the Jewish community, including Yiddish, Hebrew and Russian speakers. Through highly-rated foster care, developmental disability, mental health, and other programs and services, OHEL provides supportive housing, treatment, care coordination, education, outreach and much more to elevate lives and strengthen individuals and communities in New York City, Long Island, New Jersey, Florida, California and worldwide on the web. David Mandel is the CEO of OHEL.